Sawalat

[Qadri]

Asalam-o-alikum

Bhai kuch sawalat hain jin k mein jawab chahta hoon .......jo kisi nay muj say pochin hain ? ager app ko pata hon to plz meri madad karin

 

1 Abdul Qadir Jillani non SYED they kia ? kya kabi abdul qadir jilani ne ye kaha keh mein SYED hoon...?

 

2 SAHI BUKHARI

 

Sahih Bukhari Book 019, Number 4349:

 

Abu Bakr said:" I am the successor of the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him)." Both of you came to demand your shares from the property (left behind by the Messenger of Allah). (Referring to Hadrat 'Abbas), he said: You demanded your share from the property of your nephew, and he (referring to 'Ali) demanded a share on behalf of his wife from the property of her father. Abu Bakr (Allah be pleased with him) said: The Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) had said:" We do not have any heirs; what we leave behind is (to be given in) charity." So both of you thought him to be a liar, sinful, treacherous and dishonest. And Allah knows that he was true, virtuous, well-guided and a follower of truth. When Abu Bakr passed away and (I have become) the successor of the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) and Abu Bakr (Allah be pleased with him), you thought me to be a liar, sinful, treacherous and dishonest.

 

3QURAN kee tehreef ke barey mein

 

Bukhari, Muslim, Ibn Majah........ tafseer dur e mansoor by imam jalalud din syuti....

 

KE reference HAIN KIA ???

 

4 BAKRI pare kha gaee,,, ye riwayat aap ke siha sitta mein mojood hai………. Sunan Ibn Majah mein Ammi Aisha se riwayat hai keh mein ney ayat e rajm apne taqiye ke neechey rekhee thee likh ker jab Nabi Paak(saww) kee zindagi ke akhri ayam they ek bakri aee aur wo taqiye ke neeche se peta kha gaee……..???

 

BAHI YEH SAWALAT SHIA NAY MUJ SAY KARY HAIN MUJY AN KA JAWAB MIL SAKHTA HAY PLZ ?? JATNI JALDI HO SAKHE PLZ ALLAH HAFIZ

[Faizan-e-Mustafa]

1 Abdul Qadir Jillani non SYED they kia ? kya kabi abdul qadir jilani ne ye kaha keh mein SYED hoon...?

 

Shaikh AbdulQadir Jilani, al-Hasani, al-Husaini were Sayyid. Kiya app ney unka nasab shareef perha hai?

 

 

 

Aur dusra sawal kay, kiya Shaikh AbdulQadir Jilani ney yeh kaha hai kay mae Sayyid hoon ....

we know this through the following;

 

 

 

Hope this helps.

[Jad Dul Mukhtar]

ASSALAM-U-ALAIKUM WA RAHMATULLAHI TA'ALA WA BARAKATUH WA MAGFIRAH

 

QADRI BHAI APP KAY PEHLAY DONOON SAWALOON KA JAWAB TO MASHA ALLAH AZZAWAJAL SIS NAY BOHAT ACCHA DE DIA HAI, ISS MAIN MAZEED KOI OR SAWAL HO TO APP POOCH SAKHTAY HAIN??

 

APP NAY BUKHARI SHAREEF KI HADEES APP NAY DI, ISS PER ETIRAAZ KIA HAI, AGAR ETIRAAZ YE HAI KAH HAZRAT ABU BAKAR RADI ALLAH ANHU NAY SAYYIDAH FATIMA RADI ALLAH ANHA KO WIRASAT MAIN SAY HISSA NAHI DIA, TO BHAI PEHLAY APP USS SAY KAHAIN KAH PEHLAY YE SABIT KARAY KAH NABI SALLALLAHO ALAIHI WASALLAM KI WIRASAT MAIN KYA KYA THA??? OR KYA ANBIYA ALAIHIMMUSALAM KI WIRASAT HOTI HAI????

 

DOOSRA ISS HADEES PER ETIRAAZ KYA HAI???

[Jad Dul Mukhtar]

APP KA TEESRA(3) SAWAL KAH JI BUKHARI , MUSLIM, IBN MAJAH OR DUR E MANSOOR MAIN RIWAYAAT MAJOOD HAI TEHREEF QURAN KI,

 

TO BHAI APP USS SHIA RAFZI SAY KAHEEN AGAR HAIN TO BA'SANAD HAZIR KARO, PHIR USS KA JAWAB BHI LE LENA.

 

SAWAL NUMBER 4 MAIN APP NAY AIK HADEES IBN E MAJAH KI LIKHI.

 

PEHLAY TO APP USS SAY ISS KI ASNAAD POOCHAIN, JUB WO HADEES KI SANAD LAY AAYE TO PHIR APP DEKHIYE GA KAH USS SANAD MAIN AIK RAVI HAI MUHAMMAD BIN ISHAAQ, JISSAY IMAM MALIK NAY DAJJAL LIKHA, IBN E MOIN NAY ISSAY ZAEEF LIKHA, NISAYE NAY ISSAY LYESA BI'QAVI LIKHA,..........ETC

 

OR KHUD SHIA TAFSEER ""TAFSEER MAJMAUL BAYAN "" MAIN LIKHA HAI KAH

 

IN AYAAT MAIN SAY KAH JIN KI TILAWAT UTHALI GAYE HAI OR HUKUM BAQI RAHA AIK AYAT RAJAM BHI HAI.( TAFSEER MAJMAUL BAYAN, JILD 1, JUZ AWAL, PAGE 180, PUBLISH AT TEHRAAN)

 

YE TAFSEER SHIA ALIM ALLAMA TABRASI KI HAI.

 

BAQI SHIA RAFZI JO BHI ETIRAAZ KARAY, USS KA REFERNCE MANGAIN WO BHI POORA, HADEES KA HAWALA DAY TO SANAD KAY SATH HADEES POOCHAIN.

 

AGAR KAHAY TUMHARI KITABAIN HAIN TUM JA KAR DEKH LO, USS SAY KAHAIN ETIRAAZ TUM NAY KIA HAI HUM NAY NAHI, POORA HAWALA DO, APP JAHAN USS SAY SANAD MANGAIN GAY WO BAAG JAYE GA,

 

BUKHARI, MUSLIM, IBN MAJAH OR TAFSEER DUR MANSOOR KA REFERENCE ISS SAY MANGAIN, HADEES MANGAIN.

[Qadri]

JAZAK ALLAH BAHI