Mara Sawal Ha K Kya Shah Ahmed Noorani Sb Na Imam E Kaba Kabhi Manazra K Challenge Kiya Tha

[sana alvi]

Assalam O Alaikum

 

[Arif Attari]

un k door mai wahan sunni hakumat the

[Mustafaye]

.ایسا کچھ کبھی سنا نہیں 

[MuhammedAli]

salam alayqum wa rahmatullah wa barkaat,

Sunneh meh aya heh kay Maulana Noorani rahimullah alayhi ta'ala nay alal ilaan Wahhabiyoon ko munazray ka challenge deeya thah UK kee kissi conference meh. Nateejan Wahhabiyoon nay un ko banned ker deeya.

[sana alvi]

Arif Attari

un k door mai wahan sunni nai tha  

[sana alvi]

or jaha tak mana sona ha un na 

Manazra K Challenge Kiya Tha

[AbuAhmad]

 

or jaha tak mana sona ha un na 

Manazra K Challenge Kiya Tha

 

 

Yeh Sach hay k .........Saudi Najdi Ulma & Sunni/Barelwi Ulma kay mabain munazra agree howa tha.

Allama Saeed Asad nay kafi arsa pehlay ek taqreer mai  is ka bayan keya tha.

 

Is ka background Ehsan Ilahi Zaheer ke kitab "AlBarelwiya" & "Kanzul Imaan" per Saudi pabandi the. Jis per Saudi hakomat k through Najdi Ulma ko challenge kya gaya tha.Saudi hakomat nay Sunni Munazireen kay naam bhe managay thay....per os kay baad koe progress nahi hoe.

lagta hay Najdi Ulma nay Saudi Govt ko munazra karwanay se rook diya.....Pool jo khul jani the.

 

Sunni Munazireen mai Allama Saeed Asad, Allama Shah Ahmad Noorani & kuch digar Ulma ky naam the.

 

Mazeed verification and detail kay leay Allama Saeed Asad sey rabta kar lain................jazak ALLAH

[DeoKDushman]

ek munazra to talibaan se bhi ho raha tha ......yeh yeh kya karege munazra.....himmat hai inmein?  

[sana alvi]

muja Allama Saeed Asad k wo bayan

 mili sakta ha jis ma unna manazra k zeker kiya ha

[AbuAhmad]

muja Allama Saeed Asad k wo bayan

 mili sakta ha jis ma unna manazra k zeker kiya ha

mai ne 4-5 yrs pehlay sunna tha.

 

ab exactly tu yaad nahi kay bayan kahan se download kea tha....but i think kay www.NooreMadinah.net ka koe bayan tha.