Äśïm Ĵävëđ Äśïm

haan janab ap ko kafi ilm hy mujhy pata hy hadees jb wazy alfaaz majood hn aur riwayat b sahi hy ( ya kahoo k sahhih bukhari main zaef aur moazoo riwayat majood hain) ..... ham hadees pesh krty hain aur dawa wazy hota hy aagy sy apni allim ki andhi aqeedat ki base pr baat code kr dety hain aur khush ho jaty hn ham ne jawab dy dia hy ...... riwayat sy bachny ka hi hal hy ya to riwayat kaho ghalat hy ya sabit kro k likha howa nahi hy jo main ne kaha hy ..

tum logo ki bewaqoofio pr hansi nahi rukti....... fulan fulan kitaab mn yeh alfaaz nahi hn is kitaab mn to majood hn is sy ki farq parta hy k dosri riwayat main majood nahi hain ik sahi hadees main to majood hy ..... agy irlivent riwayat aur andhi aqeedat ki base pr ik 2 hadees apni kitabo sy zikar kr dia jin ki hamary liay koi ahmiyat nahi hy.... sahi muslim mn alfaaz b majood hain aur riwayat b theek hy jis sy meri dawa sahi proof hota hy simple

itny page paste krny pahly khud hi prh lety to behter tha..... pahli baari is sy mera dawa theek hy k is ayat k shan e nazool main ikhtalaaf hy .... walida sahiba wali ik riway ko to tum ne b khud theek kah dia hy..... sahaba wali jo hazrat ali a.s ki sahi sanad wali riwayat ka koi jawab nahi dia..... end pr mussayat wali baat hy mussayat wali baat baat mani nahi ja skti q k mussayab 10,11 saal baad muslim howa tha us waqt woh wahan majood b nahi tha.... ya to us ki majoodgi sabit kro ya dariyaan ka ravi batao warna musayat wali riwayat ka koi faida nahi hy

sorat tauba ki ayat 113 ka main jawab dy chuka hn... ap ne shayed prhny ki zahmat hi nahi kia hy...

falan falan mulla ne yeh kaha ..... jb k riwayat khud sub kuch kah rahi hy ... taveelo ki zarorat hi nahi hy... akhir tk naraz rahna aur janazy mn na hona fazy likha hy

mujhy pata hy tum ne jo b kahna hy janab... baat simple c hy.... jo main ne kaha hy woh is sy proof ho raha hy baqi tum loog jano tumhari kitabeen... meri baat proof nahi ho rahi to bata do..??

g bilkul jhoota kaha hy aur hadees ko b hazrat umer ki apni zubani sahi muslim main prh lo yeh lo us ka hawala...

g bilkul jhoota kaha hy yeh lo us ka hawala...

ap ka link main ne dekh yeh mera sawal ka jawab manhi hy..... hadees main likha hy ""hazrat ayesha ne kaha is ayat ko is tarha likho"" hazrat ayesha yeh sub kuch ayat main likhny ka kah rahi hy aur ap kah rahy batany k liay kaha hy. yeh to koi jawab na howa... ap ka link main ne dekh yeh mera sawal ka jawab manhi hy..... hadees main likha hy ""hazrat ayesha ne kaha is ayat ko is tarha likho"" hazrat ayesha yeh sub kuch ayat main likhny ka kah rahi hy aur ap kah rahy batany k liay kaha hy. yeh to koi jawab na howa...

main ne is mulla ki jhoot ki taraf ishara kia hy janab jo is ne speech main boly hain... is speech ko sunnany k koi etmenaan bakhsh jawab hy to number k sath mukhtasir bata den

ik to tum ne aksar bateen apni kitabo di hain.. 1. bukhari main fatima s.a ka razi na ho sabit hy.. kia tum logo k mutabiq sahi bukhari ki baat ko dosri kitabo sy rad kia jaskta hy?? 2. kia bukhari waali baat ghalat hy?? hy to reason? 3. la meeraas wali ayat ko hazrat ali a.s ne ghalat ka hy aur abu bakr aur umer dono ko jhoota hy... 4. ap ne ilm ki fazilat wali hadees ka ghalat matlb nikala hy jb k yeh hadees ""meeraas"" k bary main hain ki nahi ..

yeh qirat ka masla nahi hy janab.... agr yeh theek tha to tum loog aaj kr q nahi nahi likhty... aur riwayat tarimzi hy aur husn sahi hy.... yeh taweel fazool hy. khabar wahid nahi hy hifza ki riwayat ka b zikar kia hy tarimzi ne.

..............................

.........................................

tamam hawaly ik taraf ... kia koi sunni is ka jawab dy ga jo ham pr ilzaam lagata hy?